Eh? Scrum Master vs. Project Manager vs. Product Owner? Sound like comparing apples with oranges. However, in real life, project managers lead scrum teams. Scrum Masters do need project management tools and techniques.
I’m asked this kind of questions so many times that I decided to create this in-depth article on roles in different project management frameworks.
So, let’s get clear once and for all.
Watch This Article
Who is a Project Manager?
A project manager is a person who applies knowledge and skills of project management to lead a project from its initiation to successful closure.
But in the real world, the sphere of influence and responsibilities of a PM goes far beyond a project.
A project manager operates within ten major knowledge areas:
- Integration Management
- Scope Management
- Schedule Management
- Costs Management
- Quality Management
- Resource Management
- Communication Management
- Risk Management
- Procurement Management
- Stakeholder Management
But I would also add:
- Industry Awareness
- Business Acumen
So, a project manager should select required processes, tools, and techniques for the given project:
It doesn’t mean a PM uses them all. But he or she do know them and best practices to apply each one to the benefit of a project.
Project Manager vs. Program Manager vs. Portfolio Manager
Project Manager leads one or several separate projects.
Program Manager works with several related projects that pursue a bigger common goal. She focuses on higher-level management of these projects. It includes interdependences, risks, economics of the whole program as well as work required to coordinate the work of several project managers
Portfolio Manager works with groups of programs, separate projects and other actives aimed to achieve one strategic goal.
Levels of a Project Manager
Hierarchy of may look as follows:
- Senior Project Manager
- Project Manager or Mid-level PM
- Junior PM
- Assistant Project Manager or Project Coordinator
Project Coordinator is usually a person who reports and helps to Project Manager. He has limited authority to make decisions.
Who is a Scrum Master?
Scrum Master is a specific role prescribed in one framework – Scrum.
In terms of the knowledge areas that Scrum framework describes, a Scrum Master covers a little fraction of knowledge areas of project management.
Many people believe that Scrum Framework is entirely self-sufficient. In real life, Scrum Masters face the need to manage other aspects of a project as well.
Scrum Master vs Project Manager? Is it a Myth?
Theoretical agile and plan-driven worlds cannot co-exist in one project. Mindsets, roles, processes, and artifacts are that different. And yet in real life, you will often see an agile project manager leading a scrum team.
Is it really a confrontation or just a confusion around the implementation of different frameworks?
I remember my early days as PM. When I knew little about philosophies of agile, PMBOK® Guide, or any approaches at all.
(By the way, the latest PMBOK® Guide Six Edition goes hand in hand with Agile Practice Guide.)
The debates around scrum were confusing for me. Nevertheless, Scrum worked well for me without all prerequisites. Anyway, at some point several questions arose:
- Does a PM need a Scrum Master Certificate?
- Can a PM be a Scrum Master?
- Should a PM be a Scrum Master at all?
- How should Scrum Master interact with PM?
Before we get to answering these question, I want you to understand the root cause of the confusion in regards to Scrum Master vs Project Manager problem.
Where is the “Project Manager” Role?
As you may know, scrum prescribes specific roles, artifacts, and events. However, it is also the source of uncertainty:
It says nothing about cost, risk, schedule, HR or stakeholder management at all.
Moreover, many other vital aspects of a project are left without clarification.
Also, there is no Project Manager role there.
But it is even worse than that.
The only place where a PM has a chance to interact with a Scrum Team is a Sprint Review. Otherwise, he or she is considered as a distraction.
The level of authority of a Scrum Master outside the Scrum Team is unclear.
In most cases, he is considered as a team member. Therefore, has little influence on powerful stakeholders.
Here is what Scrum Guides says about the Scrum Master’s responsibilities in regards to the performing organization:
The Scrum Master serves the organization in several ways, including:
- Leading and coaching the organization in its Scrum adoption;
- Planning Scrum implementations within the organization;
- Helping employees and stakeholders understand and enact Scrum and empirical product development;
- Causing change that increases the productivity of the Scrum Team; and,
- Working with other Scrum Masters to increase the effectiveness of the application of Scrum in the organization.
If you read the Scrum Guides carefully, you will see that interactions beyond the prescribed roles are not specified.
Moreover, there is no responsible person to do that. However, Scrum Teams doesn’t live in a vacuum detached from performing organization and business in general.
These aspects create a lot of debates.
How to Resolve the Problem?
Depending on a Scrum Coach, you may learn that there are two major visions.
Scrum Team should provide value to the product owner. Nothing else really matters. Therefore, the team should be self-sufficient and able to resolve all the problems. While value is generated for the Product Owner, other metrics (financial, productivity, etc.) are of no real use.
There should be an environment around the Scrum Team that supports all their needs. Therefore, they should not be distracted from their main priority – generate value for Product Owner.
Both approaches require considerable organizational changes. Moreover, it is Scrum Masters who should drive them.
There are several apparent problems here. First, Scrum Masters usually doesn’t have authority and power to drive any changes. Second, there is no ready-made plan to transition to agile on an organizational level.
Therefore, it isn’t really a solution.
Nevertheless, Scrum found it’s application. Though, in some cases with modifications.
Possible collaboration between Project Manager and Scrum Master
In regards to the ratio of the Scrum Master vs. Project Manager interaction, there are three major groups. Names of the frameworks may vary so don’t focus too much on that.
1. Pure Scrum
The framework implemented to the latter with agile mindset as the cornerstone. There is no project manager here at all, only prescribed roles. Scrum Master works with the Team, Product Owner, and interacts with the performing organization.
2. Agile Project Management Approach
Here a PM selects processes, tools, and techniques he sees appropriate. He retains key roles and responsibilities of a project manager. However, the deliverables are implemented incrementally and in iterations. For example, using Scrum framework. Therefore, additionally, PM assumes a role of a Scrum Master.
So, Scrum here is just a tool. Some may say that it is not really Scrum, therefore, may (will) not be efficient. Mainly because agile principles are replaced with plan-driven ones.
I will only say it works just fine. Any tool properly applied in skillful hands will work. The rest is the philosophical debates.
3. Scaled Agile Framework
Here a project manager works with a number of Scrum Teams that develop parts of one product. Each team has it’s own Scrum Master and (quite often but not always) a Product Owner. Therefore, project manager oversees the whole project. In general, has the same responsibilities by in a larger scale.
In this case, a PM should interact with Scrum Masters to get the required inputs. In general, these are standardized sprint-based and increments reports.
Though, you should not confuse the role of a Project Manager with a Program Manager here. The latter is responsible for a group of projects and their collaboration in general. The difference may be quite slim here.
Do I need a Scrum Master Certificate?
Before enrolling for certification consider the following:
- Do you have extra money or can you get a sponsorship? The Scrum Master certifications together with preparation courses are costly.
- Does your industry require it? Besides the all-around buzz and hype Scrum is widely used only in several industries. For example, Software Development and Information and Communications Technology industries. For you, it may not be the best choice.
- Do you really need to know Scrum in details? Or I can put it in other words. Do you need to be able to integrate and apply pure scrum?
If one of the answers is “No” than “Scrum and XP from the Trenches” will be just enough for you.
Otherwise, I would suggest you get the certificate. If you are lucky with your Scrum Coach, you will learn a lot of small things that are not written in the free books and resources. Simply because they will be explaining everything in details for several days.
Project Manager Vs Product Owner
The Product Owner is responsible for maximizing the value of the product.
However, even Scrum Guide agrees that it is done differently in different organizations.
Using the same diagram Product Owners responsibilities cover the following knowledge areas:
It means that a Product Owner takes on the following from a project manager:
Stakeholder Management by Product Owners
A PO should be the only point of interaction between project stakeholders and project team.
It means she should work with others to decide the project goals. Product Owner should balance the needs and requirements of different stakeholder. She should also resolve all conflicting requirements before making changes in Product Backlog.
Scope Management by Product Owner
Product Owner also should translate the business requirements from different sources into User Stories.
It means that a PO also acts as a Business Analyst at some level.
Moreover, all activities related to initial “Collect Requirements” processes is on her.
Scrum simplifies the requirements management to a backlog. However, it doesn’t describe how to select and justify features and themes. This process should follow the processes in the company.
Responsibility for a Project by Product Owner
Scrum Team is responsible for delivering an increment of required quality. However, the overall responsibility for the project success and its definition is on the PO.
It means that PO should control project’s goals, manage budget, release timeline, and risks.
Conclusion: Project Manager vs Product Owner
All in all a Product Owner is a Project Manager who is responsible for the project success and project environment. But at the same time, he delegated daily management of the project team to a Scrum Master.
There are two ways to understand the problem of Scrum Master vs Project Manager:
- Scrum is a self-sufficient framework and should not be mix with other project management approaches.
- Scrum is a subset of project management that uses a selected set of tools and techniques to perform work and deliver value. It doesn’t exclude the possibility of integration with other processes. Therefore, it can be customized.